The Pressure to Know: When Not Knowing Feels Like Failure
- Shaelyn Cataldo
- May 27
- 3 min read

For years, I refused to stop and ask for directions. Even when I was hopelessly lost, something in me would tighten at the thought of pulling over, rolling down the window, and admitting I didn’t know. It wasn’t just about finding the right road—it was about what it meant to be seen in uncertainty. Underneath it all was a quiet, crushing shame that said:
"You should already know this."
(And yes, this was before the days of GPS—when asking a stranger was often the only way to reroute.)
🧠 When Knowing = Safety
This isn't just about directions. It’s about survival.
I see this belief show up all the time in my work with clients—especially those who grew up in high-pressure, emotionally unpredictable, or chaotic. In those systems, not knowing often meant being criticized, overlooked, or left behind.
So a part of you stepped up. A part that learned to anticipate, research, prepare, stay two steps ahead. A part that became the one who knew.
In many families—especially larger ones—children were quietly deputized into the emotional labor of the household. They became caregivers, organizers, emotional buffers. They figured things out, because someone had to. Because their parents were overwhelmed, under-supported, and often trying to survive themselves.
This is a personal wound with a systemic backdrop: A culture that fails to support parents especially mothers. A society that glorifies self-sacrifice. A system that doesn’t make space for asking, resting, or not knowing. Over time, knowing became your role.
And your worth got tangled up in it.
🎭 The Part That Carries It All
This part is often praised. It looks like high functioning. It sounds like “You’re so organized,” or “You always know what to do.” But inside, it can feel like pressure. Perfectionism. Exhaustion. And it’s usually protecting something much younger and more tender: The child who was left to figure it out alone. The teen who was praised for maturity but never allowed to be messy. The one who learned: if I don’t know, I don’t belong.
This part isn't bad. It’s brilliant. It adapted. It kept you safe. It gave you something to hold onto. But it’s tired now. And it may be time to ask: What if you didn’t have to hold it all anymore?
💻 When the Internet Feeds the Fear
In today’s culture of constant input, this part has endless ways to stay activated.
There’s always another podcast. Another expert. Another post that says this is the thing you’ve been missing. And while information can be empowering, it can also be addictive—especially when it’s trying to soothe an unhealed wound.
The more you feed this part, the more it craves because it’s not really hungry for knowledge. It’s hungry for relief, for permission to rest and for someone to say: You don’t have to earn your place by having all the answers.
💬 A Gentle Invitation
If this resonates, I invite you to pause—not to fix, solve, or research—but simply to notice.
Bring to mind something uncertain in your life right now. Something unresolved. Something foggy.
Ask yourself with compassion:
– Is there a part of me that feels responsible for knowing?
– What is it afraid would happen if I didn’t?
– How long has it carried this role?
– Has it ever been praised or rewarded for its knowing?
Then gently shift to your body:
– Where do I feel this pressure to know?
– Is there a tightness, a buzzing, a bracing?
– What happens if I thank this part—not for being right, but for trying so hard?
Let yourself pause. Let the question hang. Let this moment be enough.
🌙 In the Space of Not Knowing
You don’t need to know everything. You don’t need to be everything.
You get to be here, in the mystery. Not-knowing is not failure. It’s not weakness.
It’s space. Its presence. It’s the quiet breath between chapters. Sometimes, the part of you that doesn’t know is the one that finally gets to rest.
So let this part rest. Let this part lay it all down. Let this part feel held, not hurried.
I'm rooting for you-
Shaelyn
Comments